New gas proposal

Generated 2026-06-10 07:09:53Z · fork osaka · anchor_rate 100 Mgas/s

Note: this is a bundled snapshot of the analysis output. The accompanying figures (heatmaps and per-parameter provenance plots) are omitted here; the figure-rich version is published on the live analysis site linked from the EIP’s discussions-to thread.

Summary: 18 parameters proposed — 1 increased, 16 decreased, 0 new, 0 unresolved · 0 warnings · 3 poor-fit selections

Contents

Proposed gas parameters

Gas param Current gas Proposed gas Diff Diff %
OPCODE_DIV 5 2 -3 -60%
OPCODE_SDIV 5 2 -3 -60%
OPCODE_MOD 5 2 -3 -60%
OPCODE_SMOD 5 3 -2 -40%
OPCODE_ADDMOD 8 3 -5 -62%
OPCODE_MULMOD 8 4 -4 -50%
OPCODE_KECCAK256_BASE 30 12 -18 -60%
OPCODE_KECCAK256_PER_WORD 6 3 -3 -50%
PRECOMPILE_ECRECOVER 3000 841 -2159 -72%
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_BASE 0 94 +94 n/a
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_PER_ROUND 1 1 0 0%
PRECOMPILE_BLS_G1ADD 375 236 -139 -37%
PRECOMPILE_BLS_G2ADD 600 277 -323 -54%
PRECOMPILE_ECADD 150 108 -42 -28%
PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE 45000 8247 -36753 -82%
PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_PER_POINT 34000 11712 -22288 -66%
PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION 50000 23825 -26175 -52%
PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY 6900 3814 -3086 -45%

Client comparison

Worst client vs. second-worst client per gas parameter. The Ratio column is worst gas / second-worst gas — values close to 1× mean the worst case sits next to the rest of the field, while large ratios flag the worst client as an outlier.

Gas param Worst client Worst gas Second-worst client Second-worst gas Ratio
OPCODE_DIV besu 2 erigon 2 1.00×
OPCODE_SDIV besu 2 erigon 2 1.00×
OPCODE_MOD besu 2 erigon 2 1.00×
OPCODE_SMOD besu 3 erigon 2 1.50×
OPCODE_ADDMOD besu 3 erigon 2 1.50×
OPCODE_MULMOD besu 4 nethermind 4 1.00×
OPCODE_KECCAK256_BASE besu 12 geth 9 1.33×
OPCODE_KECCAK256_PER_WORD nethermind 3 besu 2 1.50×
PRECOMPILE_ECRECOVER erigon 841 geth 781 1.08×
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_BASE erigon 94 besu 41 2.29×
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_PER_ROUND besu 1 erigon 1 1.00×
PRECOMPILE_BLS_G1ADD ethrex 236 besu 175 1.35×
PRECOMPILE_BLS_G2ADD ethrex 277 besu 212 1.31×
PRECOMPILE_ECADD erigon 108 reth 96 1.12×
PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE reth 8247 ethrex 8182 1.01×
PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_PER_POINT nethermind 11712 ethrex 6162 1.90×
PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION ethrex 23825 nethermind 23399 1.02×
PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY ethrex 3814 erigon 1411 2.70×

Per-client proposed gas for each parameter. Cells are colored by log2(proposed / current) — red means the proposal is more expensive than the current gas cost, green means cheaper, and white sits at unchanged. Annotations show the absolute proposed gas value; blank rows are parameters with no prior baseline (see warnings below).

Worst-case provenance per gas param

One collapsible block per gas parameter showing every per-client candidate that the worst-case selector saw. Rows are model combos (the source regression’s test_name, target_opcode, model_coef_name, and any model_by factors — components constant within a parameter are dropped from the label). Cells carry each candidate’s proposed gas; bold values mark the cell the per-client selector picked.

Single-combo parameters omitted (see proposal table for the sole estimation): OPCODE_DIV, OPCODE_SDIV, OPCODE_ADDMOD, OPCODE_MULMOD, PRECOMPILE_ECRECOVER, PRECOMPILE_BLS_G1ADD, PRECOMPILE_BLS_G2ADD.

OPCODE_MOD — 4 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
63 2 1 1 1 1 1
127 2 2 2 2 2 1
191 2 2 1 2 2 1
255 2 2 1 2 2 1
OPCODE_SMOD — 4 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
63 2 1 1 1 1 1
127 3 2 2 2 2 1
191 2 2 1 2 2 2
255 2 2 1 2 2 1
OPCODE_KECCAK256_BASE — 4 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
0 10 8 2 9 3 2
32 11 8 2 9 3 2
256 12 8 2 9 3 2
1024 11 8 2 9 3 2
OPCODE_KECCAK256_PER_WORD — 4 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
0 2 2 2 2 3 2
32 2 2 2 2 3 2
256 2 2 2 2 3 2
1024 2 2 2 2 3 2
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_BASE — 2 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
test_blake2f_benchmark 34 60 5 11 16 39
test_blake2f_uncachable 41 94 6 14 17 38
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_PER_ROUND — 2 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
test_blake2f_benchmark 1 1 1 1 1 0
test_blake2f_uncachable 1 1 1 1 1 0
PRECOMPILE_ECADD — 5 combos × 6 clients
Label Combo
M1 test_name=test_alt_bn128 / target_opcode=ECADD / model_coef_name=target_coef / param_bn128=add
M2 test_name=test_alt_bn128 / target_opcode=ECADD / model_coef_name=target_coef / param_bn128=add_infinities
M3 test_name=test_alt_bn128 / target_opcode=ECADD / model_coef_name=target_coef / param_bn128=add_negative
M4 test_name=test_alt_bn128 / target_opcode=ECADD / model_coef_name=target_coef / param_bn128=double
M5 test_name=test_alt_bn128_uncachable / target_opcode=ECADD / model_coef_name=target_coef
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
M1 62 72 58 39 44 59
M2 37 58 15 11 21 38
M3 39 58 21 17 27 36
M4 66 72 59 41 48 61
M5 90 108 91 61 76 96
PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE — 2 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
test_alt_bn128_benchmark 4593 5023 4762 4431 6641 4688
test_ec_pairing 5106 4746 8182 4134 5277 8247
PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_PER_POINT — 2 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
test_alt_bn128_benchmark 2622 2965 5890 2647 10230 5796
test_ec_pairing 3314 3986 6162 3918 11712 6080
PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION — 2 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
test_point_evaluation 17308 17849 23631 19795 21566 19784
test_point_evaluation_uncachable 20841 19423 23825 19224 23399 19664
PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY — 2 combos × 6 clients
Combo besu erigon ethrex geth nethermind reth
test_p256verify 834 1405 3804 1169 859 843
test_p256verify_uncachable 1090 1411 3814 1184 875 842

Warnings

Missing parameters

None.

Incomplete client coverage

None.

Missing glue adjustments

Priced glue opcodes with a poor fit — 28 (glue_opcode, client) fits skipped

p_value >= glue_contribution_p_value_threshold (0.05) or rsquared < glue_contribution_rsquared_threshold (0.5) — the contribution of these (glue_opcode, client) fits was skipped when computing the glue adjustment, so the listed gas params carry a target coefficient that is not net of this glue opcode’s runtime on the affected clients. See glue_opcodes_autogenerated_report.md for per-fit metrics.

Glue opcode Affected clients Affected gas params
AND erigon (R²), ethrex (R²) —
CALLDATALOAD besu (both), erigon (R²), ethrex (R²), geth (R²), nethermind (R²), reth (R²) OPCODE_ADDMOD, OPCODE_MOD, OPCODE_MULMOD, OPCODE_SMOD
EXP erigon (R²), nethermind (both) —
GT besu (R²) PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_BASE, PRECOMPILE_ECADD, PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE, PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY, PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION
JUMP besu (R²) OPCODE_ADDMOD, OPCODE_MULMOD
JUMPDEST besu (R²) OPCODE_ADDMOD, OPCODE_MULMOD, PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_BASE, PRECOMPILE_ECADD, PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE, PRECOMPILE_ECRECOVER, PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY, PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION
JUMPI besu (R²), erigon (R²) PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_BASE, PRECOMPILE_ECADD, PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE, PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY, PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION
KECCAK256 besu (R²), erigon (R²), ethrex (both), geth (R²), nethermind (both), reth (both) —
LT besu (R²) —
MSTORE reth (R²) OPCODE_KECCAK256_BASE, PRECOMPILE_ECPAIRING_BASE, PRECOMPILE_ECRECOVER, PRECOMPILE_P256VERIFY, PRECOMPILE_POINT_EVALUATION
RETURNDATASIZE besu (R²), erigon (R²) —
SELFBALANCE besu (R²), nethermind (R²) —
SWAP besu (R²) —

Poor-fit selections

Rows where the winning fit’s p-value exceeded modeling.poor_fit_p_value_threshold (0.05) or its R² fell below modeling.poor_fit_rsquared_threshold (0.5). The failing threshold(s) are noted alongside each row; selections in ### Winners with poor fit still drive the proposal, while ### Other weak candidates lists losing candidates that the selector dropped in favor of a qualified alternative. See runtime_estimation_autogenerated_report.md for per-fit runtime_ms, pvalue, and rsquared metrics.

Winners with poor fit

Gas param Client Test Target opcode Coef runtime_ms pvalue rsquared Failed
PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_PER_ROUND reth test_blake2f_benchmark BLAKE2F num_rounds 0 1 0.9896 p-value
PRECOMPILE_BLS_G1ADD ethrex test_bls12_381 BLS12_G1ADD target_coef 0.002351 0.001 0.05318 R²
PRECOMPILE_BLS_G2ADD ethrex test_bls12_381 BLS12_G2ADD target_coef 0.00277 0.001 0.06885 R²

Other weak candidates

PRECOMPILE_BLAKE2F_PER_ROUND — 1 weak combo
Test Target opcode Coef Combo Failing clients
test_blake2f_uncachable BLAKE2F num_rounds — erigon (p-value), reth (p-value)